UPDATE 12:30am Monday, December 16
A Charlotte County deputy has been killed during a traffic stop, underscoring the dangers faced by law enforcement. The tragic loss of Corporal Elio Diaz has left a profound sadness in the community and the sheriff’s office.
In a poignant moment just before midnight on December 16th, Sheriff Bill Prummell candidly expressed his grief to reporters, sharing a heartfelt reflection on why Corporal Diaz was so cherished. “Elio was a friend, a good family man, and a truly great officer,” he remarked, his voice heavy with emotion.
As the sheriff spoke, no questions were entertained. He conveyed that Corporal Diaz had initiated the traffic stop at a Chevron gas station, conveniently located near the Sunseeker resort, during a routine patrol on Sunday afternoon. The nature of the stop remains unclear, but what unfolded shortly after created a situation none could have anticipated. The driver, identified as Andrew Mostyn Jr., brandished a rifle and opened fire, critically injuring Corporal Diaz, who subsequently succumbed to his injuries in the hospital.
In the aftermath, Sheriff Prummell reported that a manhunt led deputies to a Popeye’s restaurant close to Kings Highway, where Mostyn Jr. was located.
The tense confrontation escalated when Mostyn Jr. reached for his weapon again, prompting deputies to defend themselves. One deputy fired, hitting him in the head. Despite being airlifted for urgent medical care, the suspect ultimately did not survive.
“I want you guys to keep Elio and his family in your thoughts,” Sheriff Prummell urged, his struggle to maintain composure evident. He paused, allowing the weight of his words to resonate. “He was a loving father and a dedicated community servant, and he will be sorely missed.” Corporal Diaz had joined the Charlotte County Sheriff’s Office in 2013, and his commitment to the community was unwavering.
The tragic event raises numerous questions about the violent reaction from Mostyn Jr. and the circumstances surrounding the stop. FOX 4 will be diligent in seeking clarity on this matter as the investigation unfolds.
UPDATE 9:45pm Sunday, December 15
In an expression of solidarity, U.S. Senator Rick Scott publicly mourned the loss of the deputy through a message posted on X, extending his condolences to Sheriff Prummell and the entire sheriff’s office.
“Devastated to hear of the passing of a Charlotte County deputy tonight. I spoke with @CCSOFLSheriff Prummell to let him know Ann and I are praying for his team and the deputy’s family tonight. Please keep them in your prayers.”— Rick Scott (@SenRickScott) December 16, 2024
Earlier in the evening, FOX 4 observed numerous sheriff’s vehicles stationed outside ShorePoint Health Port Charlotte, a stark reminder of the events that transpired.
The tragic incident has resonated throughout the community, highlighting the daily risks that law enforcement officials assume in their commitment to public safety. A viewer even captured video footage that showcased the tense atmosphere outside the Popeye’s, illustrating the gravity of the situation.
UPDATE 8:20pm Sunday, December 15
As hours passed, FOX 4 awaited confirmation from the Charlotte County Sheriff’s Office. Reports of potential shootings were circulating, but clarity had yet to arrive. The sheriff’s office referenced the coordination of multiple agencies across two active scenes, indicating the seriousness of the situation.
U.S. Congressman Greg Steube also took to X, addressing the evolving nature of the situation. His comments hinted at the gravity of the events unfolding in Charlotte County.
“My office is closely monitoring the reports of multiple shootings, including a potential officer-involved shooting in Charlotte County near the Sunseeker this evening. Please avoid the area to allow Charlotte County Sheriffs Office and Punta Gorda Police investigate.” — Congressman Greg Steube (@RepGregSteube) December 16, 2024
UPDATE 7:15pm Sunday, December 15
The northbound lanes of the US-41 Bridge to Port Charlotte have been reopened by law enforcement, a small sign of recovery in the wake of chaos. As the sun set, deputies remained on-site at the gas station, meticulously gathering evidence, attempting to piece together the night’s events.
Since the incident began, it has cast a long shadow over the area. Senior Reporter Kaitlin Knapp earlier noted the anticipation surrounding Sheriff Prummell’s impending statement, as the community yearned for answers.
Original Reporting:
Following the tragic events, law enforcement responded quickly, cordoning off access around the Chevron gas station across from the Sunseeker resort. As the investigation unfolded, the area remained tense, bearing witness to the fragility of life and the unpredictable nature of violence.
Charlotte County’s FOX 4 Community Correspondent Alex Orenczuk shared his firsthand observations as he remained in close proximity to the locations essential to the unfolding story. Eyewitnesses provided conflicting reports; some mentioned hearing gunshots, while others were unsure, creating an environment filled with uncertainty.
While calmer now, the tension in the air suggests that the impact of this tragedy will linger, prompting many to reflect on the sacrifices of those in law enforcement. The emotional weight of this loss serves as a stark reminder of the dangers these officers face daily. Kaitlin and Alex continue to monitor developments as the community processes this unimaginable loss, urging all to remain vigilant and supportive as they navigate this painful chapter.
